As a relative newbie I recently purchased the Barista Express and Barista Pro from Costco for £365 and £450 respectively. I will only keep one machine however I do have a dilemma in choosing between the two.
I did a quick comparison extracting espresso on both machines:
Rave signature beans (medium/dark) roasted on 27 Dec.
Tested on 3 Jan.
Manual shot with 8s pre-infusion.
Barista Pro (upper burr at setting 5)
Grind setting 6, Dose - 19g, Yield - no extraction (grind too fine), Time -N/A
Grind setting 8, Dose - 19.1g, Yield - 42g, Time - 35s
Grind setting 9, Dose - 19.1g, Yield - 43g, Time - 28s
Barista Express (upper burr at setting 3)
Grind setting 5, Dose - 19g, Yield - 40g, Time - 33s
Grind setting 6, Dose - 19g, Yield - no extraction (grind too coarse for 19g dose), Time - N/A
Grind setting 6, Dose - 17.9g, Yield - 41g, Time - 29s
There is more adjustment available on the Pro grinder (30 steps vs. 18) and more reliance on changing dose on the Express in order to fine tune the extraction. The technical team at Sage did however confirm that the lowest and highest grind settings on the Express and Pro are the same, only the Pro has more steps in-between.
The Pro starts up in 3 seconds vs. approx 30 seconds on the Express and is also quieter in use. The built in timer on the LCD screen is useful. I did however find the portafilter included with the Pro is a much tighter fit.
I don't find the omission of the pressure gauge on the Pro to be an issue - it was initially useful on the Express to indicate the lowest grind setting was not fine enough (upper burr adjustment required). However when brewing it can be misleading if anything, especially if used in conjunction with the guidance provided in the Sage manual.
Stretching milk was an interesting experience. The wand on the Express has a single hole tip and can consistently produce textured milk for latte art, which takes around 1 min for a 240ml latte. The Pro has a 4 hole tip which I found difficult to use to begin with. I can't use the same technique as I do with the Express and I believe the wand needs to be kept more vertical instead of at an angle. If you get the orientation right and with some practice (I hope), I believe the extra power will produce a better microfoam. It takes approx 45s for a 240ml latte (haven't timed yet). Does anyone have experience texturing milk on the Pro?
I'm leaning towards keeping the Pro especially with a price difference of £85. The steps on the Express grinder are much too far apart. As beans age, I feel like the integrated grinder will dictate what extraction you have to make do with as opposed to offering finer control to the user. The Pro may reduce a need to purchase a separate grinder in the near future. Interested to hear people's thoughts.
I did a quick comparison extracting espresso on both machines:
Rave signature beans (medium/dark) roasted on 27 Dec.
Tested on 3 Jan.
Manual shot with 8s pre-infusion.
Barista Pro (upper burr at setting 5)
Grind setting 6, Dose - 19g, Yield - no extraction (grind too fine), Time -N/A
Grind setting 8, Dose - 19.1g, Yield - 42g, Time - 35s
Grind setting 9, Dose - 19.1g, Yield - 43g, Time - 28s
Barista Express (upper burr at setting 3)
Grind setting 5, Dose - 19g, Yield - 40g, Time - 33s
Grind setting 6, Dose - 19g, Yield - no extraction (grind too coarse for 19g dose), Time - N/A
Grind setting 6, Dose - 17.9g, Yield - 41g, Time - 29s
There is more adjustment available on the Pro grinder (30 steps vs. 18) and more reliance on changing dose on the Express in order to fine tune the extraction. The technical team at Sage did however confirm that the lowest and highest grind settings on the Express and Pro are the same, only the Pro has more steps in-between.
The Pro starts up in 3 seconds vs. approx 30 seconds on the Express and is also quieter in use. The built in timer on the LCD screen is useful. I did however find the portafilter included with the Pro is a much tighter fit.
I don't find the omission of the pressure gauge on the Pro to be an issue - it was initially useful on the Express to indicate the lowest grind setting was not fine enough (upper burr adjustment required). However when brewing it can be misleading if anything, especially if used in conjunction with the guidance provided in the Sage manual.
Stretching milk was an interesting experience. The wand on the Express has a single hole tip and can consistently produce textured milk for latte art, which takes around 1 min for a 240ml latte. The Pro has a 4 hole tip which I found difficult to use to begin with. I can't use the same technique as I do with the Express and I believe the wand needs to be kept more vertical instead of at an angle. If you get the orientation right and with some practice (I hope), I believe the extra power will produce a better microfoam. It takes approx 45s for a 240ml latte (haven't timed yet). Does anyone have experience texturing milk on the Pro?
I'm leaning towards keeping the Pro especially with a price difference of £85. The steps on the Express grinder are much too far apart. As beans age, I feel like the integrated grinder will dictate what extraction you have to make do with as opposed to offering finer control to the user. The Pro may reduce a need to purchase a separate grinder in the near future. Interested to hear people's thoughts.